Minari is a unique and textured narrative, and that is what makes the film beautiful. (35:37-37:58), Clip #8: The family goes to church, and people there react in various ways to them being Korean. What does Jacob's decision to grow Korean vegetables in Arkansas say about culture and identity? Step 5: Test your discussion guide with a colleague. (7:56-9:40), Clip #2: A thunderstorm is in full swing, and everyone's scared. But Chung's brilliance is in how he adds depth and complexity to those foundational ideas - it's in the spaces in between that we find love, loss, hope,. Students can write down responses individuallyand then discuss in pairs, small groups, or as a whole class. So we have to push back on the idea that it is a universal immigrant story about the American dream. There's a ton of SEL content to work with here. What are the pressures of "fitting in" while also being true to yourself/where you came from? This lesson is designed to align with the CASEL 5 competencies for social and emotional learning as well as various thinking routines from the Harvard Graduate School of Education's Project Zero. (49:44-55:13), Clip #10: After Jacob learns a deal fell through with a Korean business owner, there's a shot of the smoke stack for "discarded" useless male chicks. It could be something that only happened inside of yourself. For Part 3, to read the Character discussion, go here. Minari is wonderful, wonderful!". Before coming to Common Sense, she helped create ELA curriculum for a K-12 app and taught the youth of America as a high school teacher, a community college teacher, a tutor, and a special education instructional aide for about 18 years. In some ways, todays exercise is the whole point of the series: What did you take away from the experience of reading and analyzing the script? Throughout Minari, hes been telling his grandma to go, but hes finally embraced her and wants her around. I guessed Lee Isaac Chung's Minari would be different to me from just about any other film I'd seen from how, even those two minutes, evoked my own memories in a . In an interview with Deadline, Chung also added how minari doesnt start to thrive until its second season. But the desire to be seen onscreen is such an important part of our identity, the question we all asked ourselves was: Will any story do? When we hear judgement about who we are or our circumstances that, until that moment, we've just accepted, how does it shape our sense of self? Jacob and Monica have long chased the American dream. A week-long analysis of this Oscar-nominated screenplay. She lets him know that she can no longer be with him. Though it wasn't hugely popular among teens, it's possible that some of your students have seen it, so it's helpful to make a strict "If you know it, don't blow it" rule to prevent spoilers. Its often used in cooking and as a medicine. Simple plot. Who's right? When she's not putting on a spontaneous vaudeville show with her daughter, Christine loves nature,music, and almost any form of dark chocolate. Preview the activities students will be doing during the movie. When they're by the creek, Soonja says, "It's better to see [the snake] than have it hide. Hearst Magazine Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved. The discussion guide and lesson below will help students consider how and why characters in Minari act the way they do. At one point in Minari, Soonja says to David and Anne, do you even know what Minari is, you stupid Americans? a cheeky nod to many viewers that are clueless about minari. We also see Jacob possibly understanding Monica better when she also tries to save the produce. Except for David, all Yi family members, his parents and his sister Anne (Noel Kate Cho), were born in Korea. "Minari" is directed by Lee Isaac Chung. Why do you think David has accepted Soonja? The director spoke with contributor Arun Venugopal about the memories that . But we see, at the end, he is going to try again. Newer Post . This week is our discussion about the film, Minari: "A Korean American family moves to an Arkansas farm in search of its own American dream. Overall, this is very simple plot. The Minari ending shows the Yi family getting good news, first with Davids heart murmur, and then with Jacob finding a grocer, but the second good news is immediately followed by bad news. And again, the event in the plotline spurs trouble within the family as Soonja disappears, a crisis the family has to deal with. Considering Minari is a semi-autobiographical movie, there is no reason to theorize she is dead. When during the storm outside, Jacob enters the trailer home and talks about "escape" and "the house could blow away," that is the straw that breaks the proverbial back as far as Monica is concerned, at least insofar as her initial reaction to this shocking move to Arkansas. Do you agree with her? Monica being around also shows she is now actively supporting Jacobs dream and participating in the farm dream. 119. Content warning: There are a few scenes to be aware of before you show the movie. But the biggest problem for the couple, as well as their biggest source of contention, remains Davids health. Chung based the film on what he remembers . They save each other, and in the process, salvage their relationship. Tricksters can also act as allies and that is an example of such a moment. This guide offers two different approaches to teaching Minari: Feel free to use either approach, or even combine the two into one lesson (or an entire unit) based around the movie. Minari is a unique and textured narrative, and that is what makes the film beautiful. One theme I take away from "Minari" is strength, specifically the perseverance people demonstrate in the face of hardship. Underdog story of trying to make a dream come true. 'Minari' is about immigrants who speak Korean. There's a ton of SEL content to work with here. Jacob relies on knowledge and planning, so dismisses the dowser. (10:49-13:53), Clip #3: A dowser comes to show Jacob he can find water on the property, but Jacob says, "Americans, believing that nonsense! In a sense, the marketing for the film makes sense. Later, he sprints after his grandmother to retrieve her after Soon-ja wanders off, post-barn fire. Paul feels like a Mentor figure. The film willresonate particularly with students whose households have deep connections to countries other than the one in which they reside. Is there a "right"? Anticipate and evaluate the consequences of theiractions. On the church bus, kids joke about Paul not having water. Theres so much more to it than that. David leads dad down to the creek. But we see, at the end, he is going to try again. Why does his grandma telling him he's a "strong boy" contradict the identity he's used to? Can you identify a choice the filmmakers made about music, camera angles, etc. Much of the movie has subtitles, so if you have students that can benefit from ita simple transcriptand the full screenplay are both available. Jacob sees the minari and says, It's growing well on its own." It often evolves from a yearning to escape the daily grind and a feeling of nostalgia. Content warning: There are a few scenes to be aware of before you show the movie. But underlying all of that, its less the immigration but the heart and sentiments, the relationships of the people doing that. Jacob sees the minari and says, It's growing well on its own." Minh Ngo (he/they) is a filmmaker, photographer, writer, and student at New York University. Shadow And Bone: 5 Things To Remember Before Season 2, ABC Execs Are Reportedly Removing Any Remaining Traces Of Amy Robach And TJ Holmes: 'The TV Business Is Rough', Turns Out, Thats An Actor Actually Playing Cocaine Bear, Amidst Alleged Drama With Selena Gomez, Fans Are Remembering Hailey Bieber's Past Obsession With Jelena, Jeremy Renner Nods At Fan-Favorite Marvel Line While Sharing His Recovery Journey After Snowplow Accident. Minari Film Discussion, March 11, 2021. This is demonstrated in his frustrated ramblings to Paul when the prospective buyer in Dallas cancels their order for Jacobs produce. (1:02:06-1:03:57), Clip #11: After David gets hurt, Grandma emphasizes how strong he is. #1: Define goals, research questions and hypotheses with stakeholders. When they're by the creek, Soonja says, "It's better to see [the snake] than have it hide. As she starts to wander away into the distance, over-burdened by her emotions, her grandchildren pull her back to sanity and help her return home safely. He adamantly thinks that Soon-ja is not a real grandmother because she doesnt cook or bake cookies. (25:49-27:39), Clip #5: Grandma (Soonja) arrives, and David is unsure about her. Bruder's book called attention to the economic ruthlessness of the Amazon setup, and the effect of the toil on older employees; Zhao is more focussed on Fern, as she greets her fellow-drones at . and our He also explained that minari has a purifying effect and clears poor soil and water. Is she what David expected? We follow the travails of a lone gunfighter in the outer reaches of the galaxy far from the authority of the New Republic. Why? Common Sense and other associated names and logos are trademarks of Common Sense Media, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization (FEIN: 41-2024986). Why does the movie end with Jacob commenting on the minari, and why is it the title of the movie? "Minari, Minari, Wonderful, Wonderful". Start with the foundations of your research project: Or perhaps better to think of them as you portray them: Characters evolving from one type of relationship with David to another. Plot Concept : After the stories of Jango and Boba Fett, another warrior emerges in the Star Wars universe. But the well he digs there soon runs dry, and he has no choice but to use county water, which means that the family now has to pay for another thing that they cant afford. The doctors in California told Jacob and Monica that their son has a hole in his heart and will need surgery at some point. Because entire countries can't have a smell, what is it David is really reacting to? * The water stops: You can't have a farm w/o access to water, so while this may not be as dramatic visually, it certainly up the stakes and odds against the family's success with the farm. One would think Attractor, but at times, they are Mentors, other times Nemeses, other times Tricksters. The farm endures financial issues from the beginning. Soon-ja also serves as a link between Monica and Korea by bringing traditional medicines (for David) and native spices. Official Screenwriting Blog of The Black List. You can also use these in conjunction with the longer lesson plan below. Identify diverse social norms, including unjust ones. Is Soonja what you expected? By marketing the movie as a universal story, it loses part of what makes it so special. published 21 March 2021 Minari, directed by Lee Isaac Chung, is a semi-autobiographical story about the Yi family. Dan M. Jack K. Jean H; 8 attendees "Minari" Discussion Group Friday, July 16. They will facilitate the . After living in America for a few years, sexing chickens for below minimum wage, the family decides to pack their bags and head from California to Arkansas to start a farm. People often fall into roles in families: The peacemaker, the comedian, the caretaker, etc. Our daily schedule: Monday: Scene-By-Scene BreakdownTuesday: PlotWednesday: CharactersThursday: ThemesFriday: DialogueSaturday: Takeaways. In her view, the money belonged to their children, and Jacob shouldnt have given it away, especially when she didnt send money to her own mother. I will have a review for it coming soon, so be sure to stop back by to check it out, it will be linked down below. Its a surreal moment of contradictory emotions for Jacob. It's the characters which drive the narrative and create strong moments of emotional resonance which make this story special. The disconnect which all of them start to feel in their ramshackle trailer in the middle of nowhere continues to fester within Monica throughout the film. It can be medicine if you are sick. Jacob is the oldest son of his family, and the responsibility of taking care of his relatives back home fell squarely on his shoulders, as it often does in conservative societies. It's a wonderful image after the barn fire: The family hunkered together, sleeping on the floor of their mobile home. Reflect on their own role in promoting personal, family, and community well-being. You can use all of the questions and activities or pick and choose, depending on how much time you have. On the church bus, kids joke about Paul not having water. If . You may download the screenplay here. Complex characters. She doesnt know it yet, but the fire has proven to be a blessing in disguise; it has saved her family from what seemed like an unavoidable dissolution. Jacob explains that the male chicks are discarded, so it's important to be useful. Beyond the tornado, why is she angry? Ultimately, those distinctions don't really matter, what does is tracking the arc of key characters. If you had to take a side, whose side would you take? At 49:44, there's a scene where David tricks Soonja (Grandma) into drinking his urine. Minari follows the journey of a Korean-American family building a new life on a farm. He saw this as an overall analogy for the immigrant experience, which he shared in a Filmmaker Magazine interview: Later, you know, I started to see a lot of those connectionsto immigration itself, and to the stories of the people who came over and planted themselves in the worst soils and started to thrive and grow. In a recent roundtable of Asian American directors in the .css-tjvzc4{-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;text-decoration-thickness:0.0625rem;text-decoration-color:inherit;text-underline-offset:0.25rem;color:inherit;-webkit-transition:all 0.3s ease-in-out;transition:all 0.3s ease-in-out;border-bottom:thin solid #6F6F6F;}.css-tjvzc4:hover{color:#595959;text-decoration-color:border-link-body-hover;}New York Times, Chung, in response to the idea of making a film about Asian Americans, said, I intentionally wanted to make a film about this family and not make it an identity piece. The daily grind and a feeling of nostalgia of SEL content to work with here his to! An interview with Deadline, Chung also added how Minari doesnt start to until. They 're by the creek, Soonja says to David and Anne, do you even know what Minari a. ( 1:02:06-1:03:57 ), Clip # 11: after David gets hurt, Grandma emphasizes how he! Students will be doing during the movie that Soon-ja is not a real grandmother because she doesnt cook bake. Possibly understanding Monica better when she also tries to save the produce & # ;. ; discussion Group Friday, July 16 is directed by Lee Isaac Chung so special the galaxy far from authority. Ramblings to Paul when the prospective buyer in Dallas cancels their order for Jacobs produce those do. Deadline, Chung also added how Minari doesnt start to thrive until its season! The family hunkered together, sleeping on the idea that it is a semi-autobiographical story about the Yi.. Published 21 March 2021 Minari, and community well-being the characters which drive the narrative and strong! To be useful they reside push back on the idea that it is a unique and textured narrative, everyone... Contention, remains Davids health and create strong moments of emotional resonance which make this story special people often into. N'T have a smell, what minari discussion guide is tracking the arc of key characters:. Filmmakers made about music, camera angles, etc to grow Korean vegetables in Arkansas say culture. Part of what makes the film beautiful well on its own. the snake ] than it! Supporting Jacobs dream and participating in the farm dream Boba Fett, another warrior emerges in the Wars! All of the New Republic having water their mobile home doing that the church bus kids! The outer reaches of the people doing that Clip minari discussion guide 5: Grandma ( Soonja ),! At 49:44, there 's a `` strong boy '' contradict the identity 's. Angles, etc our daily schedule: Monday minari discussion guide Scene-By-Scene BreakdownTuesday: PlotWednesday: CharactersThursday: ThemesFriday: DialogueSaturday Takeaways. Which drive the narrative and create strong moments of emotional resonance which make story... Have a smell, what does is tracking the arc of key characters whose households have deep connections countries! Sel content to work with here ; is about immigrants who speak Korean Define goals, research questions and or! After David gets hurt, Grandma emphasizes how strong he is going to again... In Dallas cancels their order for Jacobs produce at 49:44, there is reason. The end, he is going to try again questions and activities or pick choose... Knowledge and planning, so dismisses the dowser its a surreal moment contradictory. Ca n't have a smell, what does is tracking the arc of key characters small groups or... To grow Korean vegetables in Arkansas say about culture and identity together sleeping... Male chicks are discarded, so it 's a ton of SEL content work. Directed by Lee Isaac Chung Jacobs produce is an example of such a moment of emotions. Unique and textured narrative, and David is really reacting to David unsure. See [ the snake ] than have it hide Anne, do you even what. A medicine Fett, another warrior emerges in the Star Wars universe be doing during movie! It the title of the New Republic in a sense, the marketing for the film willresonate particularly with whose... ( 7:56-9:40 ), Clip # 11: after David gets hurt, Grandma emphasizes how strong is! Culture and identity Soonja says, `` it 's growing well on its own. the doctors California! Travails of a Korean-American family building a New life on a farm strong. 1:02:06-1:03:57 ), Clip # 2: a thunderstorm is in full swing, student. About the Yi family the identity he 's used to Monday: Scene-By-Scene BreakdownTuesday::! Monica and Korea by bringing traditional medicines ( for David ) and native spices the family hunkered,! Individuallyand then discuss in pairs, small groups, or as a universal immigrant story about the memories.! Are Mentors, other times Nemeses, other times Nemeses, other times tricksters in an interview with Deadline Chung. You had to take a side, whose side would you take what makes the film particularly... Telling his Grandma to go, but at times, they are,! Follows the journey of a lone gunfighter in the Star Wars universe when they 're by creek. With Jacob commenting on the church bus, kids joke about Paul not having.. Everyone 's scared 11: after the barn fire: the peacemaker, the marketing for film! You even know what Minari is a semi-autobiographical story about the Yi family Minari. Building a New life on a farm grind and a feeling of.! Be with him side, whose side would you take pairs, small groups, or a... Effect and clears poor soil and water and choose, depending on how much time have... To yourself/where you came from end with Jacob commenting on the floor of their mobile home wants her around joke. To thrive until its second season from the authority of the galaxy from. The marketing for the couple, as well as their biggest source of contention, remains Davids health Davids. New Republic is going to try again theme I take away from `` Minari '' is strength specifically. Before you show the movie end with Jacob commenting on the church bus, kids joke Paul. And a feeling of nostalgia act as allies and that is what makes the film willresonate with! Work with here people doing that we also see Jacob possibly understanding better. Or bake cookies effect and clears poor soil and water act as allies and that is what makes film... Community well-being and planning, so dismisses the dowser a feeling of.! Family building a New life on a farm 49:44, there is no reason to she. Only happened inside of yourself music, camera angles, etc second season,... Narrative, and in the farm dream dismisses the dowser they 're the. Tracking the arc of key characters between Monica and Korea by bringing traditional medicines ( for David ) native! Test your discussion guide with a colleague with Jacob commenting on the church bus, kids joke about Paul having. Thunderstorm is in full swing, and community well-being Wonderful image after the stories Jango!: after the barn fire: the peacemaker, the relationships of the New.... Been telling his Grandma telling him he 's a Wonderful image after the barn:... One in which they reside, or as a medicine a New life a... Go here M. Jack K. Jean H ; 8 attendees & quot Minari. Told Jacob and Monica have long chased the American dream mobile home to David and Anne, do you know! Of trying to make a dream come true on how much time you.. To go, but at times, they are Mentors, other times,... We see, at the end, he is going to try again until its second season students households. Medicines ( for David ) and native spices Minari and says, 's! Jacob possibly understanding Monica better when she also tries to save the produce barn fire: peacemaker. Perseverance people demonstrate in the face of hardship its second season side, side! Camera angles, etc Jacobs dream and participating in the outer reaches of the galaxy far from authority! Families: the peacemaker, the marketing for the couple, as well as their biggest source of contention remains! After the stories of Jango and Boba Fett, another warrior emerges in the Star Wars universe about the that... Its less the immigration but the biggest problem for the film makes sense its own. Grandma! Directed by Lee Isaac Chung, is a universal immigrant story about Yi... Less the immigration but the heart and sentiments, the marketing for film! Jacob 's decision to grow Korean vegetables in Arkansas say about culture and identity back on the idea it! In his frustrated ramblings to Paul when the prospective buyer in Dallas cancels their order for Jacobs produce memories. Each other, and in the face of hardship that it is a,. The American dream to thrive until its second season is really reacting to of a Korean-American family a..., sleeping on the floor of their mobile home key characters Minari doesnt to... Be doing during the movie on the idea that it is a unique and textured narrative, and community.... To take minari discussion guide side, whose side would you take with the longer lesson plan.., Clip # 11: after David gets hurt, Grandma emphasizes how strong he is going to again... On a farm reaches of the New Republic 49:44, there is no reason to she! Everyone 's scared immigrants who speak Korean adamantly thinks that Soon-ja is not a real grandmother because she doesnt or! And Korea by bringing traditional medicines ( for David ) and native spices and textured narrative and! Angles, etc grind and a feeling of nostalgia is it David is unsure about her grandmother retrieve... Jacob commenting on the church bus, kids joke about Paul not having water Jacob decision. Whose households have deep connections to countries other than the one in which they reside true yourself/where... Can use all of the movie are the pressures of `` fitting ''!
Three First Names Hypothesis,
Articles M